Skip to main content
Case Study — Alliance Against Seclusion & Restraint

The complete federal record on who gets restrained and secluded in American schools.

Prior Signal transformed two years of raw U.S. Department of Education CRDC data into an accessible, credible, interactive public record — for the nation’s leading restraint-and-seclusion advocacy organization.

98,010 schools2 school yearsAll 50 states + DCWCAG 2.1 AANo external dependencies
01 — The Brief

What AASR needed.

The Alliance Against Seclusion & Restraint is the country’s most visible advocacy organization working to end the physical restraint and seclusion of students in schools. Every two years, the U.S. Department of Education releases the Civil Rights Data Collection — the most comprehensive federal census of school discipline practices.

AASR needed a data experience that could turn this raw federal record into an authoritative, citable public reference — one their advocates, congressional contacts, and journalists could open and check.

Translate raw OCR CRDC CSV files (2020–21 and 2021–22) into a verifiable public record — honest about suppression and limitations.
Lead with disability disproportionality: AASR's central advocacy frame, supported by relative-risk and concentration metrics.
No frameworks, no CDN dependencies — the artifact must survive server shutdowns and be shareable as a single file indefinitely.
Trauma-informed editorial voice: facts without sensationalism, credibility without coldness.
02 — The Approach

Structure. Verify. Build. Design.

Prior Signal’s method for high-stakes data work: every output is ground-truthed against the official record before any design work begins. In an advocacy context, a data error is a liability.

Phase 01
Structure

Python pipeline parses and normalizes both CRDC vintages. All 14 headline figures computed independently and held for cross-validation.

Phase 02
Verify

Each figure is asserted against OCR's official "A First Look" publication. Any mismatch aborts the pipeline. Zero tolerance for data error.

Phase 03
Build

Verified data is inlined into a single HTML file. Vanilla JS only — no runtime network requests, no third-party scripts, no build toolchain to run it.

Phase 04
Design

WCAG 2.1 AA throughout. Every chart has an accessible data table fallback. Okabe-Ito colorblind-safe palette. Reduced-motion gate on all animations.

03 — Key Findings

What the data shows.

Computed directly from the CRDC record and verified against OCR’s official publications. Each figure represents a distinct dimension of the restraint-and-seclusion crisis.

77.3%
of restrained children have disabilities

Students with disabilities represent 14% of enrollment — yet account for more than three-quarters of every child physically restrained in American schools.

5.5×
relative restraint risk for disabled students

Controlling for enrollment share, a student with a disability is 5.5 times more likely to be physically restrained than a non-disabled peer.

40%
of mechanically restrained children are Black

Black students represent 15% of enrollment but 40% of children subjected to mechanical restraint — straps, cuffs, or prone-restraint devices.

3.3×
average incidents per affected child

Each affected child was restrained an average of 3.3 times in a single school year. Restraint is not a one-time event.

+127%
rise in mechanical restraint since 2017–18

Mechanical restraint grew from 3,619 to 8,219 children — more than doubling — while physical restraint broadly declined modestly.

13%
of schools suppressed all R&S data

OCR suppression rates are themselves a finding. One in eight schools reported no usable data, making the true scale unknowable from the public record alone.

04 — Deliverables

What Prior Signal produced.

Every deliverable is designed to outlast the engagement — portable, self-verifying, and legible to a non-technical audience.

01
Interactive two-year data experience

Single self-contained HTML file (~820KB). All data inlined. No server or network required.

02
Python data pipeline

14-figure ground-truth validation against OCR’s “A First Look” reports. Aborts on any mismatch.

03
Cleaned, annotated datasets

JSON + CSV for both school years. Suppression codes preserved and annotated for downstream use.

04
Static archive pages

Per-year snapshots at stable URLs for long-term citability with no JavaScript dependency.

05
Social share card suite

12 PNG crops at standard OG dimensions for Twitter/X, LinkedIn, and Facebook.

06
Methodology documentation

Source files, suppression logic, derived metrics, and reserve-code analysis — fully documented.

07
WCAG 2.1 AA audit — 20/20

Axe-core automated pass plus manual keyboard and screen-reader testing.

Prior Signal

If you have a dataset the public needs to understand, let’s talk.

Prior Signal takes on a small number of engagements at a time. Each one starts with a clearly scoped output — a verified data experience, an intelligence brief, a structured public record. No strategy decks that go nowhere.